One-Piece vs. Two-Piece Toilet: Which Is the Better Choice?

Whether you are planning to remodel your home or are just looking to build a new one, choosing the right type of toilet is very essential.

Installing a toilet at home is not something you do on a regular basis and will cost you big Over the long run if you are not sure which one you need at the time of installation.

Tip: Thinking if this doesn’t work I will change it later with the other different one can cost you big in terms of time and money. Stress is complementary.

Don’t worry, this guide will compare 7 important things you need to consider while choosing the toilet: Size and weight, Build material and durability, Maintenance Frequency, Flushing Power and Efficiency, Process and Cost to install, Space required, Total Initial Cost of installation.  

Overview:

One-piece toilets:

These are sleek-looking commode with the water tank attached to the seat, making it look pretty nice while covering a lot less space in your washroom. They are fashionable and commonly found in newly built houses or remodeled washrooms.

Two-piece toilets:

These are old classic traditional commodes that come in two pieces (tank and a bowl) and are then assembled into the final toilet. Still, the majority of US homeowners prefer two-piece toilets to one-piece toilets. You will have a toilet tank and a toilet bowl and have the option to mix and match the pieces together. These are very commonly found and also come cheaper than one-piece toilets.

Let us go in-depth comparing these key components to consider before making the decision.    

  1.  Size and weight:

One-piece toilets: You can always find a one-piece toilet as per your preferred size. They range from kid size to adult size and can stand, 10 inches to 16 inches tall. To go as per the comfort height guidelines they also come in a 17-inch size.

Usually, most one-piece toilets take up lesser space due to their sleek and compact design. The tank and bowl are attached which makes them occupy lesser space in general. Two-piece toilets can also be found in different sizes some of them also mandating comfort height guidelines. Both of them come in different shapes and sizes, to accommodate your bathroom’s layout and design.

Another important measurement while choosing a toilet is the rough-in, the distance from the center of the drainpipe to the wall behind the commode. Toilets are usually 12 inches high, but some have a 10- or 14-inch rough. Since the bowl size does not change, two-piece toilets provide more options for sitting on various sized roughs.

One-piece toilets are heavier than two-piece toilets because they have both tanks and the bowl, attached into a single mold thus making the commode heavier. This might also make the shipping and moving costs higher.

Although two-piece toilets also come in different shapes and sizes they are rarely as sleek and compact as a one-piece toilet.

  • Build material and durability.

Both one-piece and two-piece toilets are built using Porcelain or Vitreous China. Those built from Vitreous China are comparatively stronger and slightly expensive. Most of the toilets sold in the US are made from Porcelain but customers can choose which material built commode they want to buy.

As the one-piece toilet is one single large piece, there are no joining parts needed to upkeep. Proven technically, the lesser parts or connectivity, the more reliable it will be. Hence, upkeeping a one-piece toilet is super easy. There is none or very little worry of water leaking out of the tank to mess up your home.

Two-piece toilets come as separate parts and thus need pipes and gauge to connect the bowl and tank. This can create a lot of ruckus with frequent leakage and rust. But as they come in different parts, they are easily replaceable. For example, if the tank starts creating problems in a one-piece toilet you have to replace the whole commode, on the other hand only replacing the worn-out part will do for two-piece toilets.

One-piece toilets are more durable but if two-piece toilets start wearing out, replacing single parts will be cheaper than replacing a one-piece toilet.

  • Maintenance Frequency:

One-piece toilets are easier to maintain than two-piece toilets as they are inbuilt without any external rubbers or pipes to connect between tank and bowl. Unlike, a traditional two-piece there isn’t a joined part between mold and bowl and thus there are 0 chances of that uncleanable part being a breeding ground for germs and bacteria.

Also, there’s only a single commode to clean it reduces your time and effort while ensuring a very less amount of dirt and bacteria sticks into the tank.

Also, if a two-piece toilet isn’t regularly checked on there’s always chances of leakage from the joining pipes between the tank and the bowl. So, if you prefer a hassle-free and easier-to-maintain option, One-piece is always the better one.

  • Flushing Power and Efficiency

The most common and simplest system used on regular toilets is the Gravity Flush System that uses the water weight to generate flushing pressure. Water siphoning action completes the flush. There are always options to customize as per your need with adding extra tit-bits like a Dual Flush or a more eco-friendly Waterless toilet.

If compared, there is no difference between the onepiece and twopiece toilets They can have the same flushing power and efficiency.

However, https://bargainbathroom.com/, a relevant blog about washrooms and home services claims that “American Standard Elongated Cadet  Pressure Assisted Two Piece Toilet” is the best toilet seat in terms of flushing power but a  “TOTO Ultramax Toilet – Siphon Flushing” a one-piece toilet is also more or less equally good.

Thus, Key difference in flushing power can be found as per the price in both (one-piece and two-piece) toilets, making higher-end models more efficient.

  • Process and Cost to install :

The one-piece toilet is more challenging to install when compared to a two-piece due to its bigger size and weight.

To install both types of toilets, a wax ring needs to be placed over the waste pipe.

The commode is then twisted sharply to face front and placed on top of the ring at a slight angle. To equally distribute the weight, the installer sits on the toilet and leans front to back and side to side. The toilet is then bolted to the floor, with the bolts either hidden in the toilet skirt or covered with bolt caps. The water line is connected to the tank’s bottom and sealed. To search for leaks, the water is turned on and the toilet is allowed to fill before being flushed. This takes less than an hour.

Installing two-piece toilets is a lot easier as they come in separate pieces. But, without a proper plumbing skill set, you might face trouble while connecting the bowl and tank.

Installing both one-piece and two-piece toilets with professional help roughly costs around $100 -$200 so shouldn’t be a big dent on your wallet if you don’t want to get your hands dirty.

  • Space required:

The shape of the bowl if elongated occupies a larger space and two-piece toilets occupy a bit more space of the wall.

National Kitchen & Bath Association recommends that a toilet should not be closer than 30 inches center to center to any other sanitary fixture. Also, Most of the US Zip codes require at least 15 inches (measured from the center of the toilet) from any side wall or obstruction. There also should be at least 24 inches of clear space in front of a toilet or bidet.

As common one-piece toilets come with bidets, for a small bathroom it is advisable to not have a bidet to meet standard criteria.

It is thus advisable for small bathrooms to have a square or a non-elongated bowl without a bidet, and as One-piece toilets have lower profiles they make good for smaller bathrooms with the benefit of having no bulky tank gasket to leak or occupy major space in the wall behind.

  • Initial Cost:

One-piece toilets with their efficient design and the all-in-one-in-built system often come expensive. However, in recent years with an increasing number of homeowners preferring one-piece toilets the economies of scale have assisted in lowering down the costs.

A DeerValley DV-1F52813starts roughly at around $199 on Amazon with free shipping while a Kohler Gabrielle with a bidet” (higher-end model) will need you to shell out roughly $2500.

To give you a rough estimate a one-piece toilet will ask you anything from $200- $2000, thus giving you a ton of choice for your essential commodity.

As two-piece toilets are common and have been in huge demand since forever, they are cheaper than one-piece toilets. An American Standard 288DA114.020 will come around $129 on amazon making it the cheapest on the platform and a “TOTO MW746305CUMGA” (a quite fancy one with dual flush) will roughly cost you $1500 on Amazon. However, for an average consumer and an average household options ranging from $130-$300 is advisable.

With installation, you can expect to shell out 300-500 for a two-piece toilet, and somewhere between $500-$900 for a mid-tier one-piece toilet. However, as one-piece toilets are more durable and need a lot lesser maintenance a customer can look at the long run while making the decision.

Key pros and cons to consider:

One-Piece toiletTwo Piece Toilet
Pros
●Sleek looking
●Easy maintenance
●More durable
●Easy to install
●Flushing and water-saving options
Pros:
●Cheaper
●Has comparatively more options on height and style
●Easier to lift to install
●Mix and match tank and bowl
●Easier to ship and bring home
Cons
●Heavy
●More expensive
●Difficult to move and ship
Cons
●Harder to clean
●Needs more maintenance and is likely to break
●Hassle to install
●Bulky and less compact

 After looking at these different metrics, we can come to the conclusion that one-piece toilets are more efficient compared to two-piece toilets. However, if looks and comfort are what matters to you and not the hassle to maintain and durability, you can find an equal amount of options in both of them.

We can conclude that two-piece toilets are cheap and good while one-piece toilets are better but expensive. Keeping both short and long run in mind, and also making sure your wallet doesn’t get a big dent, you can choose on either of the options.

Also, to make it easier, here we have attached the most popular brands offering toilet seats in the United States (As per monthly online searches) that offer both one and two-piece toilets. You can choose your perfect seat by looking at these options and considering both pros and cons (as per your need) to find which one will suit your home the most.

Note: We hope you find this guide helpful! If you purchase something from any of the links on this website, we get a small commission on affiliate links. We really appreciate your support.

1)Kohler: A known industry leader, Kohler® creates new styles that are both artistically modern and functionally intelligent.
Look at their options:
One-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/Kohler-K-1381-0-Veil-Toilet-White/dp/B0891K7GH5/
Two-piece:
https://www.amazon.com/K-3986-NY-Two-Piece-Round-Front-Technology-Left-Hand/dp/B006XPH5IG/

2)American Standard
One-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/American-Standard-2535128-020-Height-Elongated/dp/B00OM5AG08/
Two-piece toilet
https://www.amazon.com/American-Standard-COLONY-HET-COMBO/dp/B00NO22VJY/

3)Toto
One-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/TOTO-MS854114E-01-Ultramax-Elongated/dp/B001F9YF6A/
Two-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/TOTO-CST244EF-01-Two-Piece-Elongated/dp/B00H2Y52A0/


4)Duravit
One-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/Duravit-2120010001-Toilet-Starck-1-Piece/dp/B005MTT64K/
Two-piece toilet:
https://www.amazon.com/Duravit-2130010000-Two-Piece-Toilet-White/dp/B005MTTQ54/


5)VOVO
They specialize in smart and high-end one-piece toilets only, giving you an ultra-luxury and techy feel in your washroom.
Product: https://www.amazon.com/VOVO-TCB-090S-Tankless-Integrated-Waterjet/dp/B08CMLLX8Y/

We’re an affiliateWe hope you love the products we recommend! Just so you know, we may collect a share of sales or other compensation from the links on this page. Thank you if you use our links, we really appreciate it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *